The Weird Battle Over the Debt Ceiling

Washington, DC is Exaggerating Debt Issue to Push an Agenda to Please Campaign Contributors and Hide the Real Causes of Debt

By Dean Baker
Al Jazeera, July 28. 2011

Policy debates in Washington are moving ever further from reality as a small elite is moving to strip benefits that the vast majority need and support. The battle over raising the debt ceiling is playing a central role in this effort.

The United States is currently running extraordinarily large budget deficits. The size of the annual deficit peaked at 10 percent of GDP in 2009, but it is still running at close to 9.0 percent of GDP in 2011. The reason for the large deficits is almost entirely the downturn caused by the collapse of the housing bubble. This can be easily seen by looking at the projections for these years from the beginning of 2008, before government agencies recognized the housing bubble and understood the impact that its collapse would have on the economy.

At the beginning of 2008 the Congressional Budget Office (CBO), the country’s most respected official forecasting agency, projected that the budget deficit in 2009 would be just 1.4 percent of GDP. The reason that the deficit exploded from 1.4 percent of GDP to 10.0 percent had nothing to do with wild new spending programs or excessive tax cuts. This enormous increase in the size of the deficit was entirely the result of the fallout from the housing bubble.

Remarkably, both Republicans in Congress and President Obama have sought to conceal this simple reality. The Republicans like to tell a story of out-of-control government spending. This is supposed to be a long-standing problem (in spite of the fact that Republicans have mostly controlled the government for the last two decades) that requires a major overhaul of the budget and the budgetary process. They are now pushing, as they have in the past, for a constitutional amendment requiring a balanced budget.

It might be expected that President Obama would be anxious to correct the misconception about the budget, but this would not fit his agenda either. President Obama is relying on substantial campaign contributions from the business community to finance his re-election campaign. Many business people are anxious to see the major government social programs (Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid) rolled back. They see the crisis created around the raising of the debt ceiling as a unique opportunity to accomplish this goal.

In order to advance their agenda, President Obama also has an interest in promoting the idea of the deficit as being a chronic problem. Plus, it gives him an opportunity to blame the deficit on the fiscal choices of his predecessor, President Bush. Therefore, in his address to the country on July 25, he told the public that as a result of President Bush’s tax cuts, his wars, and his Medicare prescription drug benefit, the deficit was on a track to be more than $1 trillion in 2009.

This is more than five times as large as the actual figure projected by CBO. However, President Obama’s distortion preserved the idea of the deficit as a chronic problem, while also getting in an attack on the Republicans. It also allows him to avoid talking about the housing bubble. This is a topic that he seems anxious to avoid, since many large contributors to his re-election and to the Democratic Party profited enormously from the bubble.

The claim that the deficit is a chronic problem and not primarily the result of a severe cyclical downturn also opens the door for cuts to the country’s major social welfare programs. These cuts are hugely unpopular. All three major programs enjoy overwhelming support among people in all demographic groups, including conservative Republicans. There is no way that an ambitious politician would ever suggest major cuts to these programs apart from a crisis.

In this respect, the crisis over the debt ceiling is the answer to the prayers of many people in the business community. They desperately want to roll back the size of the country’s welfare state, but they know that there is almost no political support for this position. The crisis over the debt ceiling gives them an opportunity to impose cutbacks in the welfare state by getting the leadership of both political parties to sign on to the deal, leaving the opponents of cuts with no plausible political options.

To advance this agenda they will do everything in their power to advance the perception of crisis. This includes having the bond-rating agencies threaten to downgrade U.S. debt if there is not an agreement on major cuts to the welfare state.

In principle, the bond-rating agencies are only supposed to assess the likelihood that debt will be repaid. However, they showed an extraordinary willingness to allow profit to affect their ratings when they gave investment grade ratings to hundreds of billions of dollars of mortgage-backed securities during the housing bubble. Given their track record, there is every reason in the world to assume that the bond-rating agencies would use downgrades or the threat of downgrades for political purposes.

This means that the battle over the debt ceiling is an elaborate charade that is threatening the country’s most important social welfare programs. There is no real issue of the country’s creditworthiness of its ability to finance its debt and deficits any time in the foreseeable future. Rather, this is about the business community in general, and the finance sector in particular, taking advantage of a crisis that they themselves created to scale back the country’s social welfare system. They may well succeed.

Dean Baker is the co-director of the Center for Economic and Policy Research (CEPR). He is the author of Plunder and Blunder: The Rise and Fall of the Bubble Economy and False Profits: Recoverying From the Bubble Economy.

This column was originally published by Al Jazeera.

the Lawsuits

July 27, 2011

Jeffrey St. Clair
The Politics of Make-Believe: Barack Obama, Changeling

Kim Sengupta
Libyan Rebels in Retreat

Michael Brenner
COIN of Base Metal: the Counter-Insurgency Industry

Jose David Torrenegra
Play Democracy, Hide the Corpses: Business as Usual in Colombia

Binoy Kampmark
The Madness of His Method

Paul Krassner
My Lesson in Mindfulness

Thomas Mountain
Lies of the Libyan War

Clancy Sigal
What’s So Great About Winning, Anyway?

Mark Weisbrot Jamaica Restructured: Still Drowning in Debt

Michael Calderón-Zaks
Who Will Protect Us From the Police?

Website of the Day
US Used Hiroshima to Bolster Support for Nuclear Power

July 26, 2011

Michael Hudson
Obama’s Ambush on Entitlements

Franklin C. Spinney
Afghan Sitrep: We’re Here Because We’re Here Because We’re Here…

Marshall Auerback
Worse Than Herbert Hoover

Dean Baker
The Drive to Cut Social Security Benefits

Shaukat Qadir
Has Pakistan Declared Independence From the US?

Michael Brenner
Oslo and the War on Terror

David Swanson
Even the Birds Have Left Afghanistan

James Zogby
No Standing O for Obama

Ron Ridenour
Cuba’s Revolution: Morality & Solidarity

Binoy Kampmark
The Death of Amy Winehouse

Website of the Day
Chernobyl: a Field Trip to No Man’s Land

July 25, 2011

Patrick Cockburn
The Limits of Airpower

Vijay Prashad
Palestine’s Norwegians

Andrew Levine
Is There Life After Obamamania?

M. G. Piety
The “Sextual” Instinct

Karl Grossman
Radiation is Good for You?

Diane Christian
Righteous Killing

Martha Rosenberg
Pesticides in Your Toothpaste (And Other Legal Dangers)

Mark Weisbrot
The Real Problem With US Health Care

Carl Finamore
San Francisco Police Claim Harding Shot Himself

Robert Bryce
Vietnam’s War on Carbon Limits

Murray Dobbin
Time for a Culture War in Canada

Website of the Day
Dead TVs

July 22 / 24, 2011

Alexander Cockburn
Apocalypse Nigh?

Paul Craig Roberts
An Economy Destroyed

Uri Avnery
The Charge of the New York Times

Ismael Hossein-Zadeh
Why All the Wrangling Over the Debt Ceiling?

Jeffrey St. Clair Flesh and Its Discontents: the Paintings of Lucian Freud

David Price
94 Seconds in the Tour de France

Franklin Lamb
Student Questions From Tripoli

Ramzy Baroud
Ground Your Warplanes, Save the Horn of Africa

Karl Grossman
What Could Truly End the Space Program: a Nuclear Accident Overhead

George Ciccariello-Maher /
Jeff St. Andrews
Every Crook Can Govern

Ralph Nader
Whatever Happened to Corporate Patriotism?

Saul Landau
Rupert’s Empire of Slime

Kevin Kamps
Atomic Power in a Destabilized Climate

Paul Street /
Anthony DiMaggio
Blaming the Tea Party

Sam Smith
When Congress Goes Mad

Steve Breyman
Explaining Obama

Carol Murry /
Greta Berlin
Audacious Women

Charles Davis
Larry Summers and the F-Word

Ray McGovern
The Fallen-Away Jesuit: an Open Letter to Jerry Brown

Tom Englehardt
How Not to Make Friends in the Middle East

Michael Leonardi
Remembering Carlo Giuliani

John Sinclair
Revenge of the Tough Nerds: Pot’s New Cold War

Susil Gupta
Ronnie and Reggie, Robert and Rupert

David Macaray
Is This Really the Best We Can Do?

Patrick Bond / Khadija Sharife
The Earth Grabbers

Mark Weisbrot
The Occupation of Haiti Must End

Thomas Mountain
Crocodile Tears Over Famine

Dennis Bernstein
An Interview with S. Brian Willson

Michael Winship
Up the Revolution

William A. Cook
The Death of Democracy

Walter Brasch
Moses’s Candidate

Farzana Versey
Kashmir’s American Counsel?

Christopher Brauchli
“The Poor Should Do More!” Orrin Hatch and the Income Tax

Rajesh Makwana /
Adam Parsons
The Silent Humanitarian Crisis in East Africa

Dave Lindorff
To Hell With the Democrats!

Mark Loyka
Inequality and Poverty in Latin America

Missy Beattie
The War on Childhood

Kevin Zeese
Tim DeChristopher’s Battle for Justice

Phil Rockstroh
Bachmann, Palin, Robertson and the Limits of Logic

James Rothenberg
What’s the Difference? The Losing Game of American Politics

Charles M. Young
Nim and Noam: BF Skinner, Chomsky and the Chimp

Robert Zaretsky
In Pursuit of Idleness

Charles R. Larson
Not Bloody Likely

Gilad Atzmon
The Great Games

David Yearsley
Malick’s Tree of Cliché

Poets’ Basement
Three by Corseri

Website of the Weekend
Once There Was This Friggin’ Band, Sonny, and They Sounded Like This…

July 20 / 21, 2011

Darwin Bond-Graham
A National Park for Nukes?

Tariq Ali
Murdoch: Will Anything Really Change?

Paul Imison
Mexico’s Rule of Lawlessness

Sam Pizzigati
Understanding the Federal “Debt Crisis”

David Swanson
Balance the Budget on the Backs of Billionaires!

Steve Fake Destination? Gaza!

Israel Shamir
Why Palestine is Important

Younes Abouyoub
A “Democratic Moment” in Morocco?

Ron Jacobs
A Hunger Strike for Humanity

Mike King
A Life Worth Less Than Train Fare

Charles R. Larson
From Freud to Mugabe: Zimbabwe’s Filthy Lucre

Patrick Madden
The Police Murder of Kenneth Harding

Cal Winslow
Judge Throws Out Kaiser Elections

Website of the Day
Heat Storm, Animated

July 19, 2011

Ralph Nader
The Corporate Supreme Court

Jonathan Cook
The Method in Netanyahu’s Madness

Patrick Cockburn
Why Does Britain Insist on Punching Above Her Weight?

Mya Guarnieri
What Israeli Democracy?

Christopher Ketcham
All Hail the Draft!

Alan Farago
Marco Rubio Faces the Nation

Marjorie Cohn
Prisoners Strike Against Torture in California Prisons

John Blair
Is the Sun Setting on “Clean Coal”?

Russell Mokhiber
Why Did Andrew Cuomo Get Rid of James Sheehan?

Lisa Barr
To Cuba, With Baggage, and Love

Website of the Day
Raindrops Over Rwanda

July 18, 2011

Uri Avnery
It Can Happen Here

Bruce Page
A Real History of Rupert Murdoch

Patrick Cockburn
Bahrain Royal Personally Tortured Student Poet

Laura Carlsen
NAFTA-Look Alikes

Vijay Prashad
Droneland

Theresa Amato
The Warren Betrayal: Obama Bows to Wall Street

Dean Baker
Budget Games:
Wall Street Calls the Shots for Repbulicans

Ralph Nader
Dumping Elizabeth Warren

P. Sainath
Indian Regime Most Corrupt in Nation’s History

Stephan Salisbury
The Politics of Muslim-Bashing

Dave Lindorff
Blowing It: How the Democrats are Sinking Themselves

Caitlin R. Ringwood
Afro-Colombian Resistance in La Guajira

David Green
Youth vs. Seniors: a Fake Economic Conflict

Website of the Day
Mountaintop Removal and Birth Defects

July 15 – 17, 2011

Alexander Cockburn
NATO’s Debacle in Libya

Mike Whitney
Debt Ceiling Kabuki

Gareth Porter
Sadr’s Game

Michael Brenner
The Big Rollback

Ramzy Baroud
How the PA Sold Out Palestinian Unity

Conn Hallinan
The Walls of Paestum

Saul Landau /
Danny Glover
Danny and Saul Visit Gerardo Again

Jeff Sparrow
The Phony Populism of Rupert Murdoch

Susil Gupta
Murdoch’s Mafia

David Swanson
The Blood on Murdoch’s Hands

Laura Carlsen
Return of the Dinosaurs in Mexico

Neve Gordon
Israel’s Growing Crackdown

Eric Walberg
Israel and the Flotillas

Philippe Descamps
Russia’s Demographic Crisis

Christopher Brauchli
America Right or Wrong

David Macaray
A Strike Looms in the Grocery Industry

Jack Random
Why I Hate Texas

Rev. William E. Alberts
Bachmann’s God

Alan Farago
The Wrecking Crew

Damien Millet /
Eric Toussaint
Facing the Debt Crisis in Europe

Marica Frangakis
How the EU Made the Greek Crisis Worse

Walter M. Brasch
The Change Deficit

Jordan Flaherty
Danziger Bridge Trial: Defending Killer Cops

Karl Shepard
Jim Crow Resurrected in Florida

Jon Hochschartner
Capitalism and the Environment: an Interview with Chris Williams

Joe Allen
Free Speech in the Shadow of War

Alvaro Huerta
Striking Out in Phoenix

David Ker Thomson
Lake Nameless

Missy Beattie
The Paradox of Progress

Dr. Susan Block
The Politics of Spanking

Pradeep Baisakh
Clearing Forests and People in Odisha

Dan LaBotz
Blues on the Border

Ron Jacobs
Stopping the Train, Stopping the System

Brian Tokar
Coming of Age in a Different Time

Charles R. Larson
Pilgrim’s Progress

David Yearsley
Stetch at Full Stretch

Poets’ Basement
Church, Landau and Ramsey

Website of the Weekend
Happy Carmageddon!

July 14, 2011

Pam Martens
Conspirators Unmasked in the DSK Drama

Tariq Ali
Scenes From a Marriage: AmPak Relations

Patrick Cockburn
Libyan Rebels Ambushed

Fred Gardner
How Cannabis Works

Israel Shamir
Zizek and the Gaza Flotilla

Lawrence Davidson
Will the US Leave Iraq?

Benjamin Dangl
Grassroots Solutions to American Crises

John Grant
The Gaza Flotilla and the Blood-Dimmed Tide

Dean Baker
Economic Illiteracy: Blame the Teachers?

John Stanton
Snatching the Dead for DNA

Farzana Versey
The Mumbai Blasts

Website of the Day
Bastille Day

July 13, 2011

Anthony DiMaggio
Obama’s Political Suicide

Vijay Prashad
Libya and the War Powers Act: Obama’s Lethal Transgression

Jordan Flaherty
Occurrence at Danziner Bridge

Russell Mokhiber
Can the Labor Union Movement be Revived?

Sheldon Richman
Don’t Support the Troops, Bring Them Home!

Eric Walberg
The Killing of Ahmad Wali Karzai: From Dishwasher to Drug Kingpin

Russell D. Hoffman
San Onofre: a Trillion Dollar Threat to SoCal

Joshua Sperber
The Evils of Bad Criticism: Stiglitz and Austerity

Mark Weisbrot
Why the Euro is Not Worth Saving

Linh Dinh
Poor Richard’s Rise

Michael Winship
Get Mad at Judges, Not Juries

Website of the Day
“Don’t think, look!”

July 12, 2011

Ralph Nader
The Great Tax Loophole Swindle

Mike Whitney
From Bad to Worse

Joan Roelofs
The Deadening Silence

Patrick Cockburn
Panetta: We Need US Troops to Stay in Iraq to Fight Iran

John Isaacs
The House and the Defense Budget

Gail Dines
DSK and the Meaning of Consent

Jack Random
Prescribed Failure: No Child Left Behind and the Atlanta Schools Cheating Scandal

Alexander Reid Ross
FTA Hat Trick: Green Markets Scam Goes Hemispheric

Thomas H. Naylor
The Key to a Happy Death

Stewart J. Lawrence
Betty Ford Went Rogue

Website of the Day
My Summer at an Indian Call Center

July 11, 2011

Gregory Elich
Class War Without Mercy

Barbara Ehrenreich
War Without Humans

Franklin Lamb
France Says NATO Bombing Has Failed

Gerald Pollet Radiated Rain: Radiation Levels in Northwest Rain Were Up to 130 Times Safe Drinking Water Standards Following Fukushima

Michael Kidder
A Pipeline Runs Through It: Exxon, the Yellowstone and the Damage Done

Dave Lindorff
Voodoo Economics, 2011

Michael Brenner
The Scent of Victory? Al Qaeda and Panetta’s Nose

John O’Connor
The Suspects are in Charge of the Case

David Michael Green
Stupid Democrats, Stupid Republicans

John Blair
Reversal of Fortune for Duke Energy

Website of the Day
Drugs and the Meaning of Life

July 8 – 10, 2011

Alexander Cockburn
All the Publisher’s Men

Kathy Kelly
Greece, Gaza and the Grand Drama

Andrew Levine
Reagan Recycles Back to Life

Ramzy Baroud
The Revolt in Yemen

Marjorie Cohn
Avoiding Impunity: the Need to Broaden Torture Prosecutions

Winslow T. Wheeler
The Pentagon Remains Immune

David Rosen
AIDS at 30: Getting Worse for the Most Vulnerable

David Zlutnick
War on the Border: an Interview with Charles Bowden

Saul Landau
The Politics of Simulopting

Jason Hribal
No One Likes the Zookeeper

Olivier Aubert
The Online Sex Industry

Franklin Lamb
NATO’s War Against Libya’s Civilians

Eric Walberg
Egypt vs. the IMF: Time to Default?

Roy J. Eidelson
America’s Overcrowded Cellar

Paul Imison
Mexico: the Pretty Much Inevitable Return of the PRI

Michèle Brand
Belarus Under Siege

David Macaray
Working for Change at Walmart

Steve Breyman
Cellulosic Fantasy: Ending Corn Ethanol Subsidies

David Tresilian
French Arms for Libyan Rebels

Chellis Glendinning
The Growing Movement Against Electromagnetic Contamination

Stacey Warde
I May be Poor, But I’m Not Destitute

M. G. Piety
On Parenting

Lawrence Davidson
Flotillas and the Law

Christopher Brauchli
Banking in Fine Print

Missy Beattie
Children of War

Dave Lindorff
American Sicko

John Sinclair
Smoking Out Tourists

Lee Sustar
A Voice Fighting for CWA

Cesar Chelala
Learning From Cuban Crocodiles

Charles R. Larson
No Country for Sane Men

Rick Salutin
Bad Teacher and Why We Need Her

Kim Nicolini
The Contradictions of Bill Cunningham

David Yearsley
Borden and the Mallards: Dazzle at the Brick Factory

Poets’ Basement
LaMorticella, Costley and Davies

Website of the Weekend
Please Support the Organic Consumers Association!

July 7, 2011

Vijay Prashad
Libya as Proxy

Michael Brenner
Wealth in America: By the Numbers

Chase Madar
Why Bradley Manning is an American Hero

Russell Mokhiber
Suckerpunched on Anti-Trust

Dean Baker
Ron Paul vs. the Federal Reserve

Ann Robertson /
Bill Leumer
NEA Flunks Crucial Test

Murray Dobbin
Canada’s Afghan Blunder

Margaret Kimberley
The Evil of Two Lessers

Thomas Mountain
Ethiopia Buys Arms as Millions Starve

Thomas L. Knapp
Casey Anthony and American Justice

Website of the Day
Helplessness Blues

July 6, 2011

Robert Sandels
Soft-Powering Cuba

Alain Gresh
Egypt’s Revolution is Only Beginning

Patrick Cockburn
The Bombing of the Kabul Intercontinental Hotel

Dean Baker
Do Economists Bleed?

Michael Winship
Michele Bachmann Flunks Canadian History, Too

Alan Farago
Of Fetuses and the Everglades

Stan Cox
Can Air Conditioning Save You?

Jeff Klein
Workers Held Hostage

Kevin Carson
The Force of Law: Rights vs. Privileges

Norman Solomon
Politics of the Imperative

Website of the Day
India’s Vanishing Vultures

July 5, 2011

Franklin C. Spinney
Why the War Machine Keeps on Running

Jonathan Cook
Palestine’s Last Village Faces Bulldozers

Andy Kroll
The 60-Year Unemployment Scandal

Dean Baker
Saving Social Security From Its Saviors

Patrick Cockburn
What is Schizophrenia?

Linn Washington, Jr.
Damaged Democracy

Rich Gibson
Strange Attraction: NEA Endorses Obama

Michael Barker
Foundations and Social Change: an Interview with Adrienne Pine

Fidel Castro
A Brilliant and Courageous Statement

Ceidren Voe
The Scalpel and the Damage Done

Website of Day
UN Fails Uncontacted Tribes

July 4, 2011

Gareth Porter
Humiliation for Petraeus

Jonathan Cook
The Real Preachers of Hate

Dean Baker
Making Short Work of the Economy

Patrick Cockburn
Vicious Circles: Living With Schizophrenia

Henry Norr
A Long Train of Abuses: Dispatch from the Freedom Flotilla 2

Alvaro Huerta
From Jim Crow to Juan Crow: Alabama’s Racist New Immigration Law

Patrick Bond
South Africa’s Water Wars

Dave Lindorff
Our Incredible Shrinking Constitution

Steve Early
Victory in Vegas

Brian J. Foley
Memo to Southwest Airlines: Why Don’t You Honor All Defenders of Liberty This Fourth of July?

Website of the Day
Ribs Against Racism?

July 1 – 3, 2011

Alexander Cockburn
Pure Victims, Real Human Beings

Darwin Bond-Graham
Nuclear Fiddling, While Los Alamos Burns

Mike Whitney
Mired in a Colossal Muddle

Ramzy Baroud
At the Expense of Gaza

Neil L. Whitehead
Divine Hunger: the Cannibal War Machine

Saul Landau
Targeting Libya, Hitting the Constitution

Franklin Lamb
Dispatch from Tripoli: Countdown to Invasion

William Blum
Libya: Unending American Hostility

Ralph Nader
Leaving Elizabeth Warren Out in the Cold

Tom Engelhardt
Obama’s Military Mantra

Sarah Anderson
Taxing Speculation

Henry Cockburn
The Trees Were Calling Me: Living With Schizophrenia

Martha Rosenberg
Lost in Psychiatryland

David Macaray
On a Cross of Coal

Carol Miller
Burning the Truth at Los Alamos: Nukes, Fire and Secrecy

Robert Roth
Haiti: the Next Round

Dr. Susan Block
The Shriveling of the Case Against DSK

David Swanson
The DSK Rorschach Test

Rana B Baker
A Permit for Home: My Jerusalem Diaries

Walden Bello
Capital is a Fickle Lover

Jack Random
Austerity Bridge

Chris Genovali
Northern Gateway to Destruction?

Christopher Brauchli
Once Upon a Foreskin

Ron Jacobs
Brotherhood of Acid: Orange Sunshine and the Sixties

John V. Walsh
Stealth Bill to Approve Libyan War Defeated

Charles R. Larson
Swedish Travesty of Justice: Stieg Larsson and Eva Gabrielsson

Missy Beattie
Doing the Aftermath

Stewart J. Lawrence
Is Obama Really a D*ck?

Farzana Versey
City Blights: Animal Farm and Farming People

Shahid Mahmood
A Shock of Peroxide-Blonde Hair

David Yearsley
Triumphs of the O/Modernters

Poets’ Basement: Notes From a New Baghdad by Martin Burke

Website of the Weekend
“Tonight we look at the role of the Village Idiot in society”

June 30, 2011

Linda Greene
Obama’s War on Whistleblowers

Andrew Levine
Rod Blagojevich and the Audacity of Hope

Bill Quigley /
Jocelyn Brooks
Displaced Women Demand Justice in Port au Prince

Eric Walberg
Afghanistan: Victory in Defeat?

Ray McGovern
Gaza and Thoughts of a Starving Ireland

James Zogby
Rightward Drift

Miguel Ángel Vásquez
Capulalpam: the Babel of Land Disputes

Max Suchan, Kathy Kelly and Robert Naiman
Senator Calls for US Special Forces to Attack the Gaza Flotilla

Lee Sustar
Showdown in Chicago: Rahm’s Attack on Teachers

Thomas H. Naylor
What are You Going to Do About the Empire?

Website of the Day
Ft. Calhoun Nuke: Rising Water, Falling Journalism

June 29, 2011

Henry Giroux
War Colleges

Franklin Lamb
Scenes From Tripoli

Karl Grossman
The Nuclear Gang Regroups

Harvey Wasserman
We’ve Almost Lost Nebraska

Paul Craig Roberts
A World Overwhelmed by Western Hypocrisy

David Swanson
Memoirs of Torturers

Linh Dinh
Mugged Then Shot

Kathy Deacon
Teeth, Pain and the US Drug Industry

Dave Lindorff
The US Military’s A/C Bill for Iraq and Afghanistan Gives Me the Shivers

Shamus Cooke
Labor Fights Back in Oregon

Website of the Day
Message in a Bottle: Freedom Flotilla 2

June 28, 2011

Uri Avnery
Sacred Mantras

James Bovard
Idolizing Absolute Power

Michael Winship
The Rich are Different

Andrew Bacevich
Is America Coming to Its Senses?

Alan Farago
And Not a Drop to Drink: the Salting of Florida

Ralph Nader
When Sports Loses Its Soul

Stewart J. Lawrence
Coming Out for DREAM

Laura Leigh
Killing the Wild West

Marilyn Wargo
Greed and Slaughter on the Western Range

Leonard Peltier
A Fuse Called Geronimo

Website of the Day
Assaunge Subterranean Homesick Blues

June 27, 2011

Vijay Prashad
The Undoing of Libya

Peter Lee
Imperial Rounding Error in Iraq

Patrick Cockburn
The Demonization of Gaddafi

Joseph Giambrone
Nuclear Catastrophe Imminent in Nebraska?

Jason Hribal
Understanding Class and Species

Mats Svensson
Encounter in Jerusalem

Laura Carlsen
Development and Migration: the Missing Link

Kathy Kelly
Preparing to Sail to Gaza

David Macaray
Bobby Kennedy Was No Hero

Don Fitz
The Deep Green Meaning of Fukushima

Clancy Sigal
Hemingway and Us

Website of the Day
Talking Politics, Books,Libraries, Budget Cuts and CounterPunch

June 24 – 26, 2011

Alexander Cockburn
Nail That Coffin Shut!

Patrick Cockburn
Amnesty Questions Claim That Gaddafi Ordered Rape as Weapon of War

Michael Hudson
Bankers Gear Up for the Rape of Greece, as Social Democrats Vote for National Suicide

Dave Marsh
In the Land of Hope and Dreams: Clarence and Bruce, Friendship and Race

Saul Landau
Briefings at Tiffany’s: Picture President Newt

Gareth Porter
The Open Door in Afghanistan

Andrew Levine
Obama, Still Better Than Bush?

Amira Howeidy
Revolution in Their Eyes

V. Noah Gimbel
Obama and Rendition

Ramzy Baroud
Turkey Rising

Alain Gresh
Palestine’s Own Spring

Susan Abulhawa
Writing Our Own Stories

David Rosen
America’s Tahrir Square

Christopher Brauchli
Alabama, Where Intolerance is King

Russell Mokhiber
Not Single-Payer in Vermont

Saleh El-Naami
Exposing Israel’s Most Dangerous Secret

Anthony DiMaggio
Mediated Ignorance

Kevin Carson
Our Corporate Military

Joe Giambrone
Nuclear Power? What’s the Alternative?

Steve Breyman
Bigots in Vestments

David Ker Thomson
Against Travel

Binoy Kampmark
The Eco-Sex Movement

John Sinclair
Turning Back Time in Amsterdam

Robert Jensen
The Anguish in the American Dream

William A. Cook
Obama’s Singularities

Walter Brasch
The Villification of Smokers

Helen Redmond
The Drug War at 40

Tom Stephens
Assault on Detroit

Farzana Versey
Out of the Wilders

Missy Beattie
The Mother of Intervention

Yolande Cadore
Ending the War on Drugs

Ron Jacobs
Burned at the Stake for Being Poor

Brendan O’Neill
Vajazzled in Essex

William Manson
One Tiny Voice

Colin Kalmbacher
Bedtime for Punk Rock Relevancy?

David Yearsley
Cosi Fan Tutte at Drottingholm

Poets’ Basement
Three by Cirino

Website of the Weekend
The Promise and Perils of Hook-Up Culture

June 23, 2011

Bill Quigley
Haiti, 17 Months After the Quake

Mike Whitney
QE 3? The Perils of Inflation Targeting

Phyllis Bennis
Token Withdrawals

Robert Fantina
American Hypocrisy at the UN: Equal Rights for Everyone (Except Palestinians)

Tom Engelhardt
Defining an American State of War

Linh Dinh
Sentimental Mass Murderer

Alan Farago
The Real Rubio: He’s No Outsider

Roberto Rodriguez
Fanning the Flames of Prejudice

Eric Walberg
Bilderberg vs. the SCO: Where are the Real Decisions Being Made?

John Stanton
Suicide at HTS

David Macaray
The US Needs to be More Like China

Website of the Day
Fallng Life Expectancies in the US

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Share/Bookmark

July 28, 2011

The Price of the Housing Bubble

The Weird Battle Over the Debt Ceiling

By DEAN BAKER

Policy debates in Washington are moving ever further from reality as a small elite is moving to strip benefits that the vast majority need and support. The battle over raising the debt ceiling is playing a central role in this effort.

The United States is currently running extraordinarily large budget deficits. The size of the annual deficit peaked at 10 percent of GDP in 2009, but it is still running at close to 9.0 percent of GDP in 2011. The reason for the large deficits is almost entirely the downturn caused by the collapse of the housing bubble. This can be easily seen by looking at the projections for these years from the beginning of 2008, before government agencies recognized the housing bubble and understood the impact that its collapse would have on the economy.

At the beginning of 2008 the Congressional Budget Office (CBO), the country’s most respected official forecasting agency, projected that the budget deficit in 2009 would be just 1.4 percent of GDP. The reason that the deficit exploded from 1.4 percent of GDP to 10.0 percent had nothing to do with wild new spending programs or excessive tax cuts. This enormous increase in the size of the deficit was entirely the result of the fallout from the housing bubble.

Remarkably, both Republicans in Congress and President Obama have sought to conceal this simple reality. The Republicans like to tell a story of out-of-control government spending. This is supposed to be a long-standing problem (in spite of the fact that Republicans have mostly controlled the government for the last two decades) that requires a major overhaul of the budget and the budgetary process. They are now pushing, as they have in the past, for a constitutional amendment requiring a balanced budget.

It might be expected that President Obama would be anxious to correct the misconception about the budget, but this would not fit his agenda either. President Obama is relying on substantial campaign contributions from the business community to finance his re-election campaign. Many business people are anxious to see the major government social programs (Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid) rolled back. They see the crisis created around the raising of the debt ceiling as a unique opportunity to accomplish this goal.

In order to advance their agenda, President Obama also has an interest in promoting the idea of the deficit as being a chronic problem. Plus, it gives him an opportunity to blame the deficit on the fiscal choices of his predecessor, President Bush. Therefore, in his address to the country on July 25, he told the public that as a result of President Bush’s tax cuts, his wars, and his Medicare prescription drug benefit, the deficit was on a track to be more than $1 trillion in 2009.

This is more than five times as large as the actual figure projected by CBO. However, President Obama’s distortion preserved the idea of the deficit as a chronic problem, while also getting in an attack on the Republicans. It also allows him to avoid talking about the housing bubble. This is a topic that he seems anxious to avoid, since many large contributors to his re-election and to the Democratic Party profited enormously from the bubble.

The claim that the deficit is a chronic problem and not primarily the result of a severe cyclical downturn also opens the door for cuts to the country’s major social welfare programs. These cuts are hugely unpopular. All three major programs enjoy overwhelming support among people in all demographic groups, including conservative Republicans. There is no way that an ambitious politician would ever suggest major cuts to these programs apart from a crisis.

In this respect, the crisis over the debt ceiling is the answer to the prayers of many people in the business community. They desperately want to roll back the size of the country’s welfare state, but they know that there is almost no political support for this position. The crisis over the debt ceiling gives them an opportunity to impose cutbacks in the welfare state by getting the leadership of both political parties to sign on to the deal, leaving the opponents of cuts with no plausible political options.

To advance this agenda they will do everything in their power to advance the perception of crisis. This includes having the bond-rating agencies threaten to downgrade U.S. debt if there is not an agreement on major cuts to the welfare state.

In principle, the bond-rating agencies are only supposed to assess the likelihood that debt will be repaid. However, they showed an extraordinary willingness to allow profit to affect their ratings when they gave investment grade ratings to hundreds of billions of dollars of mortgage-backed securities during the housing bubble. Given their track record, there is every reason in the world to assume that the bond-rating agencies would use downgrades or the threat of downgrades for political purposes.

This means that the battle over the debt ceiling is an elaborate charade that is threatening the country’s most important social welfare programs. There is no real issue of the country’s creditworthiness of its ability to finance its debt and deficits any time in the foreseeable future. Rather, this is about the business community in general, and the finance sector in particular, taking advantage of a crisis that they themselves created to scale back the country’s social welfare system. They may well succeed.

Dean Baker is the co-director of the Center for Economic and Policy Research (CEPR). He is the author of Plunder and Blunder: The Rise and Fall of the Bubble Economy and False Profits: Recoverying From the Bubble Economy.

This column was originally published by Al Jazeera.

Share This

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *